
post
It doesn't matter who is speaking out. The ESA is EVIL and Illegal. for calling out PRIVATE servers.
This is not about Notch or private citizens. This is about MS once again *fucking it all *up.
It matters in the sense of popularity, which is important if you want bring a message out. His voice matters because lot of people will listen, as he is not a nobody to Minecraft. Why would most people listen to me or you? In that sense it makes sense to "use" him to get the message to the people.
As others have stated, while he is correct on this issue, I wouldn't look to Notch for his opinion on anything these days.
I honestly can't even tell if Jennifer Gibbons (ESA VP of State Government Affairs who made the original statement) even has any idea what Private Servers are. It's almost as if she was equating them to something like the community run WoW servers, which regardless of the morality argument, were in fact breaking ToS by circumventing WoW's subscription fees.
In the case of Minecraft, that argument doesn't apply. Minecraft has no online subscription. Private servers were the only way to even play online until Realms. While Mojang doesn't officially support private server administration, they do provide downloads for the server binary and documentation on their official website. It's not just allowed, it's explicitly listed as a way to play.
Obviously they would prefer to push people toward Realms as an extra revenue stream, but the way multiplayer is architected in Minecraft makes this argument make zero sense.
I think the gaming community's intuition on this one is correct in that she accidentally said the quiet part out loud:
The end state of the tech industry desired by corporations is one where copies of software and even the means to compute can no longer be owned, they must be rented from the gatekeepers--i.e. "You'll own nothing and be happy."
It's not evil, it's plain stupid, why would I ever play Minecraft with my friends now if we can't control the lobby?!
Yeah, one asshole complaining about fellow assholes shouldn't be considered news, even if it is his clock's time of day to be correct.
I mean, it is news if he's the one who made the game that's being talked about.
He's LONG since divested himself of control over it (not that I wouldn't have done it for that price, either), so what he says about how it's being handled today doesn't really much matter anymore, IMHO.
Isn't notch like one step away from full blown Nazi
I mean yes, but it should be even more concerning when the sociopath thinks you might want to dial the evil down a bit.
This comment is a good summary of the situation https://lemmy.world/post/48906051/24546849
Never attribute to Malice that which can be explained by nearly terminal levels of stupidity.


top 50 comments