Just a thought, if you leave the house to buy things, you can ensure you're getting the things you actually want

I'd be hesitant to buy anything of the sort off Amazon due to the higher possiblity of fake products. I checked target.com, and I think this is the blue gel, but there's a handful of reviewers noting burns also.
https://www.target.com/p/old-spice-wild-collection-bearglove-deodorant-3oz/-/A-14898298#lnk=sametab

Pretty sure the white stuff is antiperspirant while the blue is just deodorant. Most scents have both kinds and the label should say which is which. I don't sweat much myself so the antiperspirant def iritated me years ago when I bought the wrong kind.

I'm just happy to know others acknowledge that bearglove (and wolfthorne) are the best smelling wildly available deodorants. White is antiperspirant, blue is still just deodorant.

I'm not sure if it's consistent but at least for the pure sport flavor, aluminum free = blue gel deodorant, otherwise it's the white chalky antiperspirant

One might even say your search was, Sisyphean…

This is likely due to one of two things.

1. Amazon is bucketing deodorant and antiperspirant + deodorant in the same spot so it's random what you get.
2. A retailer mislabeled their stock and it got put in the wrong bin, so people get wrong products until all that stock is gone. Amazon comingles products so changing the seller won't help.
3. The picker grabbed the wrong item. This probably isn't the case.

Deodorant is blue, deodorant + antiperspirant is white in the store. It’s also all aluminum free now which sucks. I miss the aluminum deodorant gel.

Isn't the blue kind the gel stuff? The white is the "solid" kind.

You're looking for deodorant GEL

Try out this listing: https://a.co/d/8TAr1o4

Based on what I've been seeing what you want to look for specifically is the solid red lid, that seems to be the best indicator that it's the blue gel type deodorant, whereas the clear lid seems to indicate that it's the white antiperspirant type.

Ive been using schmitts, but it's baking soda based just like that old spice probably is. I really loved using sweet pitti, which is unscented and uses mandelic acid. Imo, mandelic acid is the king of deodorants. Nothing is going to stop the sweat except aluminum though.

It would be a crazy coincidence if you were allergic to something other than aluminum in antiperspirant.