2
Is NodeBB actually a good fit for a gaming forum these days? (community.nodebb.org)
submitted 3 months ago* (last edited 2 months ago) by to c/general-discussion@community.nodebb.org
3 comments fedilink hide all child comments
 

I think a forum can still work well for gaming communities, but it probably needs to complement Discord rather than compete with it. Discord is great for quick conversations, while forums are much better for guides, FAQs, bug reports, and discussions that people might want to find months later through search.

I'm actually considering something similar for a gaming site, ''Stickwarmods'', where we publish content related to Stick War Legacy Mod APK. One thing I've noticed is that users often have detailed questions about strategies, updates, compatibility, and gameplay that are difficult to keep organized in Discord because older conversations disappear so quickly. A forum seems like a much better place for that kind of long-form discussion.

I'd also be interested to know whether anyone has had success with features like badges, solved topics, or reputation systems in NodeBB. Do those actually help encourage people to come back and participate, or is most of the engagement driven by consistently posting useful content?

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] 5 points 2 months ago

Since you mention game guides, I'll say that a traditional forum is a far better fit than Discord. The problem is convincing everyone else of that fact. Every open source project or software package seems to use Discord for its help "forums" now, but Discord wasn't designed for cumulative, searchable, long-term discussions.

To give a personal anecdote, I was trying to follow BlenderGuru's donut tutorial, and was stuck on something or other. Of course, BlenderGuru has a Discord, and there's a channel specifically for questions about his donut tutorial. I ask my question, and it flies off the top of the screen like a barrel going over Niagara Falls, never to be seen again.

Since you don't specify what game, I'm assuming you're looking to start a general gaming forum. That's probably a smarter bet than dedicating a forum to a single game, and so a much smaller pool of potential forum members. Most people may need some convincing to join a traditional forum after years of Reddit, Discord, and Facebook. You could perhaps lean into the traditional forum angle, trying to attract people nostalgic for slower, more long lasting, and personal style of communication offered by forums.

If you have the admin skills and don't expect a lot of concurrent users, a VPS is cheap, so the risk is low. I'd say go for it anyway.

  • permalink
  • fedilink
  • source
    •