This is just gutting to hear about. I'm so incredibly disappointed. I genuinely, and naively as it turns out, thought the EU "leadership" was better than this. :(
I checked my own country's MEP voting record and this shit was entirely done by the mainstream parties - even the far-right (to my surprise) tried to stop it.
If you think about it, it makes sense that those entrenched in power are the ones more interested in mass surveilance and other forms or early detection of dissent, and in most of Europe the far-right are not in power, they're the challengers and it's the mainstream parties (generally two of them, thanks to anti-Democratic non-PV voting systems) which alternate in power.
What changes with the return of Chat Control 1.0—and what stays the same:
What is coming back: US tech companies are once again allowed to scan private messages without a warrant or prior suspicion. This affects direct messages on platforms like Instagram, Discord, Snapchat, Skype, and Xbox, as well as emails via Google’s Gmail and Apple’s iCloud.
What remains unchanged: Public social media posts and files hosted in cloud storage could already be scanned without this law. Furthermore, private messages can always be reported by users, or monitored by authorities using targeted, court-ordered wiretapping.
What is still NOT being scanned: End-to-end encrypted chats, such as those on WhatsApp, have always been exempt from these scans. Additionally, European providers of messaging and email services have never implemented chat control measures.
It's a stepping stone towards more surveillance, just like every other bill that lead us here. Small enough that the populus won't riot, large enough that's it's a tangible blow to privacy and democracy.
So, what are some good encrypted alternatives to common messaging apps? Signal instead of WhatsApp/Messenger etc? Proton mail/drive/etc instead of Google? Any other suggestions? Would a mobile vpn help?
There's a number of both work and private reasons why that won't be feasible. Also, I feel that we should not surrender the whole of Internet because of this bullshit.
Signal instead of WhatsApp is generally a good idea, but WA is not covered by this law as they are end to end encrypting all messages. Switching to Proton Mail would help, using a VPN (most likely) would not.
I can't understand why anybody would trust WhatsApp. It's development and infrastructure are paid for by one of the last companies you want to trust with your private data, and they even run expensive ad spots for it. Why would they do that? Facebook is not altruistic.
Perhaps Briar? I keep wanting to try it, but don't have contacts that also do. It runs offline through Bluetooth and WiFi direct as well as online through TOR.
all 30 comments