This is just me pulling an answer out of my ass, but since it happens when we're surprised, it's probably the body reflexively taking in air so it's prepared to deal with the surprise. Which could involve fighting, running, yelling, or holding your breath for a while.
post
If I'm startled, like a jump-scare or something, I'll likely gasp, but if I see a car accident or someone falling or something explode, I'm far more likely to say "Oh shit" than gasp.
On a semi-related note, I really hate the people (mostly women, sorry ladies, and I say this as a woman myself) who scream when something bad happens, but the bad thing didn't happen directly to them, they are just witnessing the bad thing. And they scream anyway. I hate that shit.
I think it's some animal instinct thing leftover from our primitive days that's supposed to draw attention to the bad thing? But at this point in our evolution it just feels like that person is drawing attention to themselves and away from the actual issue.
What made me start thinking this was watching a lady film a boat going nuts in a marina trying to run over a guy in a seadoo and crashing into parked boats. She seems to be pretty far away from danger but keeps gasping and screaming with every hit.
You're right about the screaming detracting from the real issue though, especially if there is already a group of witnesses and you hear blood curdling screams while someone gets knocked out and then the inevitable person running in to dribble the victim's head to really make sure the spinal cord has separated.
Gasping exists as a universal reflex in at least certain cases, like jumping into frigid water. Dunno about other cases
I have a nice overexaggerated gasp I break out when the need arises yeah I was a theater kid why do you ask
Had to think on it! Yeah, I do gasp, but only when surprised and only a quick intake, pretty quiet.
Nice username, and props for going down with the ship on that instance
I have literally never gasped in my life but I've seen people do it, so I guess it's real
all 20 comments