So far none of the other soulslikes has quited scratched that BB itch for me.
I would love a new Bloodborne game if it ends up in a similar relation as darksouls to darksouls 3 - an expanded more in-depth exploration of similar subject matter. Sure the BB story is very done and I don't need a repeat of the same thing. But theres always more to explore in something so dense.
BB is still my personal favorite game and I'd love more of the same regardless of its a pre/sequal.
Also love the recommendations in the thread & comments. For sure checking them out.