THE LOVE FAIRY: Jessica Biel.
THE CRUSH: Angourie Rice.
THE VIOLINIST: Lola Tung.
THE HORNY TEACHER: Jordana Brewster.
ICE CREAM GAL: Ella Purnell.
FRIEND OF CRUSH: Jenna Ortega.
MILF NEIGHBOR: Diane Kruger.

Bro how are you going to give me Angourie Rice for free like that.

• Avengers: Scarlet Witch (Elizabeth Olsen) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• New Avengers: Kate Bishop (Hailee Steinfeld) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• Web-Heads: Arana (Isabela Merced) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• XXX-Women: Phoneix (Sadie Sink) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• XXX-Force: Psylocke (Olivia Rodrigo) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• Sisterhood of Horny Mutants: Emma Frost (Samara Weaving) - Reason: She's fucking neat.
• More Mutants: Magik (Anya Taylor-Joy) - Reason: She's fucking neat.

• ATJ (4)
• Jenna Coleman (+3=7)
• Keirnan Shipka (+2=9)
• Zoey Deutch (+1=10)
• Laufey (+2=11)
• Ellla Purnell (+3=14)
• Natalia Dyer (+2=16)

• Harley Quinn -> Lili Reinhart
• Wonder Woman -> Adria Arjona (Had to look all 3 of these up, not familiar with any of them)
• Super Girl -> Mily Alcock
• Zatanna -> Dua Lipa
• Powergirl -> Sydney Sweeney (I'm not a huge Sydney Sweeney guy, but I would have a blast just absolutely ravishing her)
• Catwoman -> Ana De Armas
• Poison Ivy -> Ella Purnell

• Bibi
• Olivia Munn
• Charlie Damelio
• Samara Weaving
• Anna Kendrick
• Kendall Jenner

• Wife: Jenna Coleman (4)
• Sister-in-Law: Vanessa Kirby (+3=7)
• Mother-in-Law: Jennifer Morrison (+3=10)

• A: Karen Fukuhara
• P: Mary Elizabeth Winstead
• M: Rita Ora
• +: Zoey Deutch

• Hailee Steinfeld
• Chloe Bennet
• Elizabeth Olsen
• Ana De Armas
• Margot Robbie

This was my logic too, but I think the expected value of each girl is actually 3.5. Possible value are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,6, so the middle is actually 3.5. So 5 is your save bet (3.5 * 5 = 1.7). 4 and 6 would put you just over and just under (expected).

Edit: Which may explain how you ended up over, but there is randomness so it's not a perfect science.

Alright, we're about to be greedy as fuck:

• Lili Reinhart
• Margaret Qualley
• Emily Rudd
• Madelyn Cline
• Selena Gomez
• Sadie Sink

• Elizabeth Banks (2)
• Vanessa Kirby (+3=5)
• Clairo (+2=7)
• Olivia Rodrigo (+5=12)

Bonus: 12 / 4 = 3

• Becca Scott (3)

Alexandra Daddario: You Dominate. Olivia Dunne: Side Fuck. Laura Vandervoort: Anal.

Emily Vancamp: You Dominate. Charli XCX: Titfuck. Isabela Merced: Titfuck.

Virginia Gardner: Lapdance. Haley Lu Richardson: 69. Olivia Cooke: Titfuck.

Kaitlyn Dever: Side Fuck. Amanda Seyfried: Titfuck. Cailee Spaeny: Lapdance.

Maggie Q: Titfuck. Olivia Rodrigo: Side Fuck. Anna Camp: Anal.

Seolhyun: 69. Emily Rudd: You Dominate. Emily Blunt: 69.

Sydney Sweeney: 69. Emma Watson: You Dominate.