I was somewhat partial to Thayer’s Witch hazel. L’Occitane makes an aftershave called Cade (made with juniper essential oil). I used that one extensively too.
https://www.thayers.com/UNSCENTED-FACIAL-TONER/THY0009.html
https://www.loccitane.com/en-us/cade-after-shave-balm-20AR075H20.html