In brief, UK reporting on "ebike" collisions and battery fires confuses lawful, UK/EU-compliant electric bicycles with illegal, unregistered, uninsured electric motorcycles. As a result, public perception is deeply skewed compared to the actual risks posed by bona-fide electric bicycles.

A similar phenomenon can be seen in California, but there is drafted legislation to mandate accurate advertising of "e-motos" versus ebikes, with fines accruing to vendors that fail to correctly represent what they're selling.

IMO, it's hard for me to blame consumers whom, given high gasoline/petrol prices, need some form of transportation that gets them where they need to go and minimizes external harms (eg automobile risk of injury). Evan correctly identifies vendors and importers that flout the law and push the legal risk into riders. At the same time, e-motos are legit for off-road use and here in California, they're great fun in that regard. At bottom, fair advertising isn't controversial; it's no different than wanting to know the ingredients in food products.

On a separate note, Evan also flagged a case of police misidentification and confiscation of a lawful e-bike. Which I find particularly surprising, given that UK police tend to be more uniformly instructed than their American counterparts. No doubt that Californian police have also confused ebikes with electric motorcycles on occasion, but the result in the UK seems is to go immediately to confiscation and destruction without any meaningful system of review. Which seems problematic, at best

you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[+] 1 point 12 hours ago* (1 child)
  • [–] 2 points 11 hours ago

    I would expect rental bikes to only really be viable in busy places where there are a lot of pedestrians. Bikes are unsafe in those areas. Even a normal acoustic bike on a slight uphill is going to be too fast to share a path with pedestrians.

    What we need in busy situations is 4 different types of trails. One for those acting like a pedestrian, one for those acting like an acoustic bike, one for that acting like a slow speed car, and one for those acting like a high speed car. Acting is important, often you can choose to operate in different ways. However these is extremely expensive and needs a lot of space so we almost always compromise and put two different uses into one and then the conflicts you describe happens: there is no easy/cheap solution.

  • source
  • parent